Chhattisgarh carnage and the anti-national media – M.N. Buch

Dantewada District, Chhattisgarh

M.N. BuchThe Naxalites are not fighting for the tribals. They are trying to annihilate the Indian state and are in a state of war with the Indian union. They are murderers and one sees no reason why they should be treated as anything else. Any sympathy for them is totally misplaced because how can one sympathise with people who kill 76 policemen in one ambush, the top leaders of a political party in another and, as has happened in one case in Dantewada, a contractor who had already paid them Rs 20 lakh as protection money.” – M.N. Buch

MaoistIn December 2012, a young woman was raped in a moving bus in Delhi, severely injured and ultimately died despite the best medical care possible. The media, especially the electronic media, went berserk. Street protests took place all over India and, in Delhi, a grave law and order situation developed. In all the media coverage I did not find a single person who supported rape as being legitimate.

Let us track forward to May 25, 2013. A convoy of senior Congress leaders of Chhattisgarh who had gone to Sukma in the Bastar division for a legitimate political rally was attacked on the way back by a large group of heavily armed Naxalites.  The 30 policemen escorting the convoy fought back, but ran out of ammunition and were overwhelmed. Veteran Congress leader Vidya Charan Shukla was hit by three bullets and thrown by the Naxalites on the road as dead. His security officer fought to the last bullet, which he used to commit suicide out of shame that he was now not in a position to protect Shukla. The Naxalites killed a total of 28 people, including policemen, but their main target was the Congress leaders. Nandkumar Patel, the state Congress chief, and his son were led into the forest and shot dead; a former MLA, Uday Mudaliar, and sitting MLA Laxman Karma were both killed and Mahendra Karma, the former home minister of Chhattisgarh, was pulled out, identified and virtually stabbed to death with his face and upper torso mutilated severely.

Ajit JogiThe only person to escape was Ajit Jogi, who had travelled to and from Sukma by helicopter. At some appropriate time a question should be asked why the same helicopter could not ferry the other top Congress leaders. At one fell blow virtually the entire senior leadership of the Congress has been wiped out in Chhattisgarh. The Naxalites have now threatened to kill chief minister Raman Singh’s associates for participating in his Vikas Yatra. How much the Naxalites represent tribal interest is proved by the fact that they feel threatened by a Vikas Yatra and Parivartan Yatra, both politically aimed at the betterment of the tribals.

The Naxalites are not fighting for the tribals. They are trying to annihilate the Indian state and are in a state of war with the Indian union. They are murderers and one sees no reason why they should be treated as anything else. Any sympathy for them is totally misplaced because how can one sympathise with people who kill 76 policemen in one ambush, the top leaders of a political party in another and, as has happened in one case in Dantewada, a contractor who had already paid them Rs 20 lakh as protection money.

I started this article with a reference to the role of the media in the Delhi rape case. In exposing various financial and other crimes committed by government and by organisations such as the cricketing establishment the media has played a commendable role. Then, why is it that when it comes to terrorism and Naxalite terrorism in particular the media is playing a role which gives the supporters of the rebels a platform to air not only their political views Swami Agniveshbut also their justification for murder and worse? The supporters are people such as Agnivesh, the Sen couple, Prof. G. Haragopal. I know Bastar because it was a part of my beat and because my brother has been both DC and commissioner in the good old days. This is not an article on Bastar and tribal grievances, if any, but in all my extensive tours of the district I have never come across more lovable or peaceable tribals than the various shades of Gonds residing in that region. This includes the Maryas, Mudiyas, Dandami Maryas and hill Maryas of the Abujmarh.

In a follow-up article I will comment on the people of Bastar and its problems, but land is certainly not one of them. The Naxalite leadership in Bastar consists of non-tribals from elsewhere, especially Telangana where the Andhra Pradesh police brought them under immense pressure so that they have moved into Bastar and into Chandrapur and Gadhchiroli districts of Maharashtra. Vidya Charan Shukla’s driver pleaded with the Naxalite leaders in Telugu and more or less convinced them that he was Telugu-speaking and that Shukla was actually a businessman. That is why both the driver and the master suffered bullet injuries but were not killed on the spot. The Gonds of Bastar speak Gondi and, therefore, the fact that the driver spoke to the Naxalites in Telugu more or less proves that the leaders at least were not from Bastar.

Prof. G. HaragopalOne thing we were taught in the IAS when I joined in 1957 was never to lose one’s presence of mind, never to succumb to anger, never to react to situations with emotion. But when I heard Nandini Sundar and Prof. G. Haragopal defend these murderers after the Darbha Ghati killings I almost felt like taking a gun and shooting these people, as also the television anchors who gave them time and space. If these killers were justified in what they did, why did we hang Kasab and Afzal Guru? My plea is that while this country can never accept censorship the media has to be selective in giving space and time to persons who are advocating the overthrow of the Indian State and actively justifying murder. How would the media react if people who favour rape were to ask for equal time?

The only member of the police force in India whom certain TV channels seem to favour is Kiran Bedi who, even in the case of Bastar, was spouting away like a geyser overflowing. The only time that she ever served in an afforested state where at one time there was an insurgency is when she was posted as DIG in Mizoram. She ran away from that state post-haste. She knows nothing whatsoever about jungle warfare or operating in a hilly and densely afforested region such as Bastar. If the media wants expert police opinion I would suggest that they call A. N. Pathak, IPS, who retired as DGP, Madhya Pradesh, and who ran a very successful anti-Naxalite operation in Bastar as zonal IGP. The media should also invite Narendra Prasad, IPS, who, as additional DGP intelligence, ran a very successful operation against the Naxalites. He also has hands-on experience of commanding a battalion of the Kiran Bedi Madhya Pradesh Special Armed Force in Nagaland when insurgency was at its height. The Thirteenth Battalion, SAF, was not ambushed successfully even once by the Nagas because it developed a high skill in dealing with guerilla warfare. These are officers who can comment on anti-Naxalite operations with a high degree of knowledge and experience. Let Kiran Bedi confine herself to traffic management in Delhi. – The New Indian Express, 7 June 2013

» M N Buch, a former civil servant, is chairman, National Centre for Human Settlements and Environment, Bhopal. E-mail:

2 Responses

  1. Perhaps Kawasi Lakma, Ajit Jogi and Sonia-G can tell us more …


  2. Chhattisgarh Maoists attack was an insider job; Info was passed to Maoists like a live commentary — Vineeta Pandey — Bhaskar News — Jun 03, 2013

    Raipur: Probing the Chhattisgarh Maoists’ attack on Congress leaders in which 29 people were killed, the National Investigation Team (NIA) has come up with startling revelations.

    According to NIA, there were some insiders who were present in Congress camp. These insiders had been giving even the minute details of Congress’ leaders to the Maoists.

    The initial probes raises “strong suspicions” about why the Maoists “singled out” state Congress chief Nand Kumar Patel and his son, brutally killing them both. The case of immediately handed over to National Investigation Agency after realising the huge political implications of the incident.

    With the unfolding of the event after May 25, it has been almost certain that the Maoists were not desperate to kill Nand Kumar Patel and his son unlike Mahendra Karma who had always been on Maoists’ radar since the time he founded the Salwa Judum. The NIA has found evidence suggesting that Patel always had “good working relations“ with his political adversaries in the state, reports said.

    According to top NIA officials, the insiders were accomplice in the brutal killings of Congress leaders in the state. These insiders had passed information related to change in route as well as who were the people sitting in different vehicles. The NIA suspects there were four people involved in this conspiracy – two were inside Congress camp, while two other were monitoring over phone.

    The information related to entire movement of the Congress cavalcade, including halt, turn, speed of each vehicle were passed to Maoists like a live match commentary. The NIA has managed to get detailed call records of the four persons from Jagdalpur cellphone towers.

    Even though various conspiracy theories are doing the rounds, NIA sources said they would submit a detailed report backed by solid evidence to the MHA in the days to come. The NIA is confident of unravelling the “conspiracy”.

    Deepak Karma, son of deceased Mahendra Karma, also believes it to be a political conspiracy. According to him, the whole incident was conspired to eliminate his father and entire top Congress line up from the state. He also revealed that his father never took the same route in any of his return journey. There was someone in the Congress camp who forced him to take the same path. Deepak holds the state government responsible for the ghastly attack on his father including other Congress leaders.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: