Today we are living in a new world in which the United States wants to be seen and acknowledged as a Great Power with no one to challenge that status. And that calls for ridiculing every other segment of thought and action that even remotely challenges America’s self-anointed superiority. Among those segments of thought hails Hinduism, brighter than a thousand suns with its intrusion in all forms of thought and action, a religion which gave to mathematics the symbol of zero and to the mind, freedom to think in its myriad ways. – M.V. Kamath
It is one of the most inevitable facts of political life that when a nation enters the rank of a great or super power, it gets fancy ideas of its superiority in all fields, political cultural or religious. It happened to the Portuguese in the 16th century when they conquered Goa. They sought to ban the people’s language Konkani and tried to downgrade peoples’ religion Hinduism by every means.
In the 19th century when the British were safely ensconced in India as the ruling party, the end result was the same, Lord Macaulay, who had been dispatched to India as legal adviser to the supreme Council of India in his Education Minute sought to belittle the country by saying that where literature was concerned he had never found one among ‘orientalists’ who could deny that “a single shelf of a good European library was worth the whole native literature of India”.
He then went on to further denigrate Indian learning as “medical doctrines which would disgrace an English farrier, astronomy which would move laughter in girls at an English boarding school, history abounding with kings thirty feet high and reigns thirty thousand years long and geography made of seas of treacle and seas of butter”.
Now in the 20th century and beginning of the 21st century we are having in the United States of America prototypes of Macaulay who can’t stand the greatness of India and who think there is no such thing as Hinduism and insisting that if there is something like that it is the product of Vivekananda’s fertile imagination, an artificial unity he constructed for political purposes.
As Rajiv Malhotra notes in his brilliant analysis of current views on Hinduism among America academia, “Vivekananda fabricated present day Hinduism by appropriating western religious and secular ideas and restating them in Sanskrit!”
Vivekananda is further charged with inventing Karma Yoga to match western social ethics and additionally to prove that Vedic traditions contain scientific merit! Writes Malhotra: “The perception that a unified idea of Hinduism lacks legitimacy has rapidly spread into mainstream intellectual circles.” It must be a sick mainstream intellectual circle indeed that thinks that way. One can only despise such circles.
But being a scholar, Malhotra had taken great pains to patiently refute theories that slander contemporary Hinduism as illegitimate and to present the most ancient religion in the world in its true light – a truth that was once accepted by an earlier batch of academicians like Emerson and Henry David Thoreau. Indeed Thoreau it was who said that he read the Gita every morning and how important it was to his own life.
And do American mainstream intellectuals remember what Robert Oppenheimer said when the US had its first nuclear bomb detonated? Oppenheimer recited a stanza from the Gita which began as: “divi surya sahasrasya bhaved yugapad uttita….” (If the effulgence of a thousand suns were to blaze forth simultaneously, that might resemble the splendour of that exalted Being). But then Emerson and Thoreau lived in another age and clime when the United States was more self-contained and had no pretence to make.
Today we are living in a new world in which the United States wants to be seen and acknowledged as a Great Power with no one to challenge that status. And that calls for ridiculing every other segment of thought and action that even remotely challenges America’s self-anointed superiority. Among those segments of thought hails Hinduism, brighter than a thousand suns with its intrusion in all forms of thought and action, a religion which gave to mathematics the symbol of zero and to the mind, freedom to think in its myriad ways.
Hinduism was prevailing long before Christ was born, long before the Holy Prophet was born, growing by the day and standing up to challenges that might have drowned a lesser philosophic entity. That it survives and even more relevantly growing by the day is the envy of America’s mainstream academicians.
Was it Newsweek (August 2009) that published a one page essay with the headline ‘We are all Hindus now’? It is not Hinduism that is picking the minds of American thinkers, it is plainly the other way round. And American academicians cannot stand being marginalised. They have to show that it is Hinduism which is borrowing ideas originating in America and the West.
The arguments pronounced by the new enemies of Hinduism are funny beyond imagination. There is this character called Van der Veer (is the word ‘Veer’ stolen from Sanskrit which gives it the meaning of ‘hero’?) who is described as “amongst the most insistent of the scholars who claim that Hinduism was created for sinister political motives”.
Veer is reported to have said that the construction of a unified Hindu identity is of utmost importance for Hindus who live outside India because they need a Hinduism that can be explained to outsiders as a respectable religion. These Hindus are known as NRIs – Non Resident Indians; but then in the United States is born another purely local sect that could also be called as NRIs (Non-Rational Imperialists). Sadly Van der Veer and his ilk, many of whom are quoted, belong to it.
Malhotra has done his job in explaining Hinduism remarkable well. He has done a brilliant job in putting the west in its place, that of an imitator. But let this be said too: Hinduism is the most ancient of all religions; it has no pope or maulvi to lay down fatwa. It has withstood terrorism of all sorts and has survived over ten thousand years and will also survive the mainstream American intellectuals with their hate-filled thoughts on Hinduism for another ten thousand years, because of its sheer intellectual and spiritual power that remains unsurpassed. – Free Press Journal, 4 May 2014
» Madhav Vittal Kamath is an Indian journalist and is a former chairman of Prasar Bharati. He was awarded the Padma Bhushan in 2004.
“Imagine a multidimensional spider’s web in the early morning covered with dew drops. And every dew drop contains the reflection of all the other dew drops. And, in each reflected dew drop, the reflections of all the other dew drops in that reflection. And so ad infinitum. That is the Buddhist conception of the universe in an image.” – Alan Watts
Filed under: india | Tagged: book review, hindu philosophy, indra's net, psychological warfare, rajiv malhotra | 4 Comments »
